It’s a Wonderful Knife 2023: A Review


It's a Wonderful Knife 2023

It’s a Wonderful Knife 2023 is a comedy-horror film written and directed by Michael Kennedy and Tyler MacIntyre, featuring Jane Widdop, Joel McHale, Katharine Isabelle and Justin Long in crucial roles. The plot tells the tale of Winnie Carruthers, who, after saving her town from a psychotic killer one year earlier, finds herself trapped in another reality with much worse conditions. Winnie must work alongside an outcast from the city to identify her killer before returning to her reality one year later.

  • Release date: It’s a Wonderful Knife was released in theaters on November 10, 2023.
  • Director: Tyler MacIntyre
  • Producers: Seth Caplan, Michael Kennedy, Daniel Bekerman


  • Jane Widdop as Winnie Carruthers
  • Joel McHale as Sheriff Mike
  • Katharine Isabelle as Gale Prescott
  • Justin Long as Harold Waters


  • Winnie Carruthers: A young woman who is haunted by the events of last Christmas and is struggling to make ends meet.
  • Harold Waters: The town misfit who is also surprisingly insightful.
  • Sheriff Mike: The sheriff of Angel Falls who is suspicious of Winnie.
  • Gale Prescott: A character named Gale Prescott, paying homage to the characters of Sidney Prescott and Gale Weathers from SCREAM.


  • It will begin streaming on Shudder on December 1, 2023
  • The film has been praised for its performances, its script, and its direction
  • It has been rated R for violence and language
It's a Wonderful Knife 2023


Winnie Carruthers (Jane Widdop) is a young woman living in Angel Falls who recently saved the town from a psychotic killer, only for things to become difficult since then, haunted by what transpired last Christmas, as well as struggling financially.

On Christmas Eve, Winnie wishes she hadn’t been born. Unfortunately, her wish is granted, and she finds herself living in a parallel universe where her life is even worse; Winnie finds her town under the control of a psychotic killer suspected of murdering herself.

Winnie must work with Harold Waters (Justin Long), an outsider in her town, to identify the killer and return to her own reality. Along the way, she must confront her demons and accept herself for who she is.


“It’s a Wonderful Knife” is an engaging and festive film perfect for celebrating the holidays. Boasting an impressive cast and clever script, its plot twists may even surprise some audiences; plus, it can sometimes get quite scary!

Widdop excels as Winnie, convincingly portraying her struggle with past traumas and anxieties. Long also stands out as Harold, an endearing but wise character with surprising insights into life.

MacIntyre’s direction of this film is outstanding, creating a suspenseful and atmospheric mood perfect for its story. Additionally, its pace never feels too slow or too fast – no matter where the viewer sits.

Kennedy has written an engaging, humorous and moving script; this film offers much to say about family relationships and the value of friendship.

Overall, “It’s a Wonderful Knife” is an enjoyable and festive film perfect for the holiday season. With an exceptional cast and creative script – not to mention some surprising scares – “It’s a Wonderful Knife” offers plenty of thrills and chills.

Critical Reception

It’s a Wonderful Knife has received generally positive reviews from critics. Rotten Tomatoes has awarded it 72% approval out of 21 studies, and its consensus reads as follows: “An enjoyable Christmas horror flick with an engaging cast and well-executed script.

Here are some excerpts from reviews of the film:

  • Variety: “It’s a Wonderful Knife is a bloody good time, a slasher film with a heart and a sharp sense of humor.”
  • The Hollywood Reporter: “A delightful and entertaining film that will keep you guessing until the very end.”
  • Indiewire: “A must-see for fans of Christmas movies and horror movies alike.”
  • Empire: “A well-made film with a great cast and a clever script.”
  • “A fun and festive film that is perfect for the holiday season.”

Overall, critics have lauded It’s a Wonderful Knife for its performances, script and direction. Additionally, audiences applauded the film’s ability to balance comedy and horror elements and its positive message regarding family and friendship bonds.


“It’s a Wonderful Knife” is an enjoyable and engaging film that will keep viewers guessing until its grand conclusion. Fans of Christmas-themed movies and horror flicks should not miss this must-see flick!

Is the movie scary?

At times it can be startlingly terrifying, yet also funny at other points. A well-made film featuring an impressive cast and clever script, The Conjuring 2 can provide some scary but humorous entertainment!

What is the message of the movie?

This movie explores the value of family and friendship as well as learning to accept oneself for who they are.

Is the movie worth watching?

If you love Christmas movies and horror flicks, It’s a Wonderful Knife is sure to keep you guessing right up until its conclusion! An entertaining film which will keep audiences guessing until its very last scene!